Cat 446 vs. John deere 510B Backhoe loaders Comparison

Compare available technical data for Loaders. Find the right details to make your decision easier.

Comparison

Highlight differences

Cat 446 Backhoe loaders

John deere 510 Backhoe loaders

Engine

Alternator supplied amperage

Alternator supplied amperage 55 Amh

Alternator supplied amperage 35 Amh

Aspiration

Aspiration Turbocharged

Aspiration Naturally aspirated

Gross power

Gross power 76.81 kw

Gross power 56.67 kw

Net power

Net power 70.84 kw

Net power 52.2 kw

Number of cylinders

Number of cylinders 4

Power measured @

Power measured @ 2,200 rpm

Torque measured @

Torque measured @ -

Torque measured @ 1,300 rpm

Torque rise

Torque rise -

Torque rise 0.22 %

Years

Years 1989-2004

Years 1991-2021

Market Average

Market Average AED 437,000

Market Average AED 199,000

Price

Price AED 158,000

Price AED 140,000

General

Backhoe digging depth

Backhoe digging depth 5.24 m

Backhoe digging depth 4.79 m

Bucket capacity

Bucket capacity 1.15 cu m

Bucket capacity 0.99 cu m

Bucket digging force

Bucket digging force 6,133.94 kg

Bucket digging force 4,445.21 kg

Bucket width

Bucket width 243 cm

Bucket width 233 cm

Displacement

Displacement 4,401.58 cu cm

Displacement 4,522.84 cu cm

Engine model

Engine model 3114

Engine model 4-276D

Loader dump height

Loader dump height 2.71 m

Loader dump height 2.68 m

Loader dump reach

Loader dump reach 0.88 m

Loader dump reach 0.76 m

Max speed forward

Max speed forward 33.15 kph

Max speed forward 35.57 kph

Operating voltage

Operating voltage 12 V

Operating weight

Operating weight 9,088 kg

Operating weight 6,985 kg

Transmission type

Transmission type Powershift

Transmission type Manual shift

Wheelbase

Wheelbase 2.26 m

Wheelbase 2.1 m

Max torque

Max torque -

Max torque 276.58 Nm

Backhoe

Backhoe reach from swivel

Backhoe reach from swivel 6.61 m

Backhoe reach from swivel 5.85 m

Loader

Breakout force

Breakout force 5,445.29 kg

Breakout force 4,173.05 kg

Loader digging depth

Loader digging depth 16.26 cm

Loader digging depth 10.16 cm

Service refill capacities

Cooling fluid cap

Cooling fluid cap 30.28 liter

Cooling fluid cap 16.28 liter

Front axle fluid capacity

Front axle fluid capacity 9.46 liter

Front axle fluid capacity -

Fuel cap

Fuel cap 125.28 liter

Fuel cap 87.06 liter

Hydraulic fluid cap

Hydraulic fluid cap 154.05 liter

Hydraulic fluid cap 79.49 liter

Rear axle fluid capacity

Rear axle fluid capacity 31.04 liter

Rear axle fluid capacity -

Transmission fluid cap

Transmission fluid cap 26.12 liter

Transmission fluid cap 79.49 liter

Refill capacities

Engine oil cap

Engine oil cap 11.36 liter

Engine oil cap 8.71 liter

Operating specifications

Extended backhoe digging depth

Extended backhoe digging depth 6.55 m

Extended backhoe digging depth 6.31 m

Extended backhoe dump height

Extended backhoe dump height 4.91 m

Extended backhoe dump height 4.24 m

Extended backhoe dump reach

Extended backhoe dump reach 3.26 m

Extended backhoe dump reach 8.53 m

Extended backhoe reach from swivel

Extended backhoe reach from swivel 7.89 m

Extended backhoe reach from swivel 4.24 m

Tires

Front tires size (2WD)

Front tires size (2WD) 14.5/75-16.1 10PR / 12.5-20 10PR

Front tires size (2WD) 11L-16, 12PR F3

Rear tires size

Rear tires size 21L-24 12PR / 21L-24 12PR

Rear tires size 19.5L-24,10PR R4

Dimensions

Ground clearance

Ground clearance 0.34 m

Height - top of cab

Height - top of cab 2.87 m

Height - top of cab 2.68 m

Overall Length

Overall Length 7.96 m

Overall Length 6.74 m

Overall Width

Overall Width 2.44 m

Overall Width 2.35 m

Turning radius

Turning radius 4.21 m

Turning radius 3.14 m

Transmission

Max speed reverse

Max speed reverse 36.53 kph

Max speed reverse 41.36 kph

Number of forward gears

Number of forward gears 4

Number of reverse gears

Number of reverse gears 4

Hydraulic system

Pump flow cap

Pump flow cap 162 lpm

Pump flow cap 132.48 lpm

Pump type

Pump type Variable flow, axial piston

Pump type 8 radial piston, closed center, variable flow, constant pressure

Relief valve pressure

Relief valve pressure 199.94 bar

Relief valve pressure 172.37 bar

Performance

Looking at performance technical specs and key features the Cat 446 Backhoe loaders excels in terms of engine power at and operating weight 9088 compared to other models like the John deere 510B Backhoe loaders.

User rating

Owners operators and fleet managers recommend the Cat 446 Backhoe loaders for its high reliability and endurance in diverse applications. The same can be said about the John deere 510B Backhoe loaders.